OK, let’s begin this off with a number of quite simple and true statements: 1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is a superb baseball participant and reigning Dwelling Run Derby champ. 2. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. can hit a baseball sooner than I can legally drive a car. 3. I’d like it if Vladimir Guerrero Jr. performed for my favourite Main League Baseball workforce.
However does that make him the best alternative for MLB the Present 24 cowl athlete? I’m on the facet of the fence that claims no.
To determine the factors by which I’m judging Guerrro as a viable cowl athlete, for me that alternative boils down to 3 components: 1. He’s bought to have that thrilling face-of-baseball enchantment like Aaron Decide, Fernando Tatis Jr. or Shohei Ohtani 2. He’s bought to be suuuper drippy like Jazz Chisholm or Javy Baez and three. He must be a wonderful on a regular basis affect participant in Main League Baseball. In my extraordinarily imperfect and subjective opinion, Vladimir Guerror Jr. is just working with a type of three components.
I’ve no beef with Vladimir Jr. I’m a Padres fan so if I’ve an issue with anybody sporting the colour blue, it’s not as a result of they play in Toronto. He performs within the AL East so he’s solely going to be an issue for my favourite workforce in the identical sense that Juan Soto now’s too.
However this isn’t about actual baseball. It’s about online game baseball, and why Vladimir Jr. won’t be your best option for this 12 months’s entry right into a online game collection we followers purchase each season.
The MLB the Present cowl athlete doesn’t all the time must be the highest participant in baseball, even if Shohei Ohtani, the undisputed greatest participant on planet Earth, graced the duvet of MLB the Present 22. However that’s additionally in all probability the rationale why Ohtani would by no means be the duvet athlete this 12 months – he was the duvet athlete two years in the past and so they’re not about to recycle him for this 12 months’s recreation.
MLB the Present 21 featured my boy, the satisfaction of the Padres, Fernando Tatis Jr. and his epic batflip. Steroid rash cream and motocross accidents or not, Tatis was completely one of the vital thrilling and marketable gamers in baseball that 12 months, and that’s the mark of the MLB the Present cowl athlete. It’s in regards to the hype and marketability of that participant.
By the best way, baseball followers can say what they need in regards to the Tatis steroid scandal – the homers he hits towards their groups this 12 months will nonetheless rely.
However I digress. The choice of Vladimir Guerrero Jr. as the duvet athlete is sort of the identical argument the neighborhood had final season, as Jazz Chisholm was the man on the duvet of MLB the Present 23. When it comes to affect, Guerrero and Chisholm aren’t that completely different, statistically (2.0 WAR vs 1.2 WAR, respectively) however that doesn’t imply that Jazz Chisolm was a nasty alternative…he wasn’t.
Though nobody would fairly name Jazz the best participant within the recreation, he’s an superior participant, one of many drippiest and most fun within the recreation. That is the man who pimps outfield throws to the plate, he performs the sport with a flourish that few others would ever even try and that’s the precise sort of power you want from an MLB the Present cowl athlete.
Among the best MLB the Present video games ever, MLB the Present 20, sported none apart from Javy Baez as the duvet athlete. I do not assume there has ever been a season the place Baez was thought of one of the best participant within the recreation however going into the 2020 season, he undoubtedly was one of many video games most fun and electrical gamers. In 2019, the Main League Baseball Instagram account was dominated by Javy Baez clips all 12 months as a result of he completely had that MLB the Present cowl athlete power.
Plus, Baez has all the time been an excellent drippy participant in the identical method Jazz is – he’s all the time rocking the chain with the cool shades and the wrist tape with customized gloves. Drip typically and obsessing over gear and tools is a part of what brings me again to MLB the Present season after season. Dripping out my ballplayer is an important a part of the expertise for me and gamers like Baez, Jazz and Tatis Jr. are good for the sport as a result of all of them deliver that drip issue to the sector.
The purpose I’m making is that by way of being an electrical, thrilling participant? I, respectfully, haven’t seen that from Vladimir Guerrero Jr. but. Don’t get me unsuitable – if the Padres someway labored a miracle and wound up with this man on the workforce (although what they really want are outfielders at this level), I’d be elated, however that’s as soon as once more not what we’re speaking about right here.
His cowl is cool – telling haters like me to shush it with the criticism. Additionally cool is the truth that it looks as if San Diego Studios is together with his shush as an in-game animation, as evidenced by the primary official screenshot depicting precisely how it will look on next-gen consoles.
He’s an excellent ballplayer, an excellent addition to the lineup of any workforce, however by way of marketability and the joy he generates for the sport of baseball, I believe there have been a number of different nice decisions that have been handed over.
For instance, think about Ronald Acuña Jr. of the Atlanta Braves. This man simply had a 40/70 season. 41 residence runs, 73 stolen bases. That has by no means occurred earlier than within the historical past of the sport. We baseball followers love to speak about Shohei Ohtani and the way he’s doing issues no one has ever completed earlier than — how about Acuña?
And once more, it’s not nearly stats it’s about being an thrilling and marketable pressure that’s gonna get folks enthusiastic about baseball? Acuña is an issue for your complete Nationwide League (together with the Padres) however I don’t know if there’s a extra thrilling participant on the sector proper now than Ronald Acuña Jr. Plus he has all of the cool drip and yellow equipment which are good for MLB the Present.
And what about José Ramirez of the Cleveland Indians? He’s been placing up enormous numbers for years and doesn’t get quite a lot of the popularity he deserves. Plus he’s tremendous drippy and he even bought a boxing knockout on the sector final 12 months. A lot of nice causes to incorporate a participant like José Ramirez.
However in fact there are doubtless unseen causes gamers like that aren’t on this 12 months’s cowl. Julio Rodriguez of the Seattle Mariners could be one other thrilling cowl athlete alternative however he was the duvet athlete for EA’s MLB Faucet Sports activities Baseball ‘23, so San Diego Studios isn’t about to show round and put him on the duvet of their recreation too.
In closing, I couldn’t be extra excited for MLB the Present 24, no matter who’s on the duvet, to be sincere. I’m an avid baseball fan, that is the closest factor to a real MLB simulator that exists, so I’m excited to show the web page on 23 and get into the brand new recreation. And as soon as once more, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is a superb ballplayer any workforce could be fortunate to have on its roster, however there have been different gamers who might have introduced a bit extra pleasure.
In any case, I’m fairly positive I’ll be consuming my phrases come mid-June when gamers utilizing Vladimir Jr. playing cards begin laying waste to my all-Padres superteams in Diamond Dynasty.
Jesse B. Gill is a video producer at IGN whose love for Star Wars is just rivaled by his love of the San Diego Padres. He’d additionally fairly not share his 2023 Diamond Dynasty win-loss file if it’s all the identical to you.